Aurelio's Pizza Reviews
Aurelio's Pizza has an overall rating of 4.3 based on 78 reviews. Customer feedback on Aurelio's Pizza is mixed: Aurelio's Pizza reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious pizza, friendly staff, quick service, great atmosphere, which strongly appeal to families, pizza lovers, local residents, casual diners. However, Aurelio's Pizza is often criticized for its high prices, limited parking, inconsistent delivery times, small seating area.
78 reviews
5 Stars
8
4 Stars
2
3 Stars
4
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
How would you rate Aurelio's Pizza?
All Aurelio's Pizza Reviews (78)
hello_joan561
May 25, 2026
"Still a dependable go-to"
I’ve ordered from Aurelio’s quite a few times now, it’s always been reliable. The pizza tastes the way I expect it to, it usually shows up hot, and the crust is always good. It’s not the most mind-blowing pizza ever, but I don’t really mean that as a bad thing. It’s just solid and consistent, and that’s probably why I keep going back
0
Reply
tiffany.Fugate
May 16, 2026
"Good pizza, but kinda light on toppings"
The pizza tasted good and the delivery was fine, but the toppings were kinda skimpy for the price. A few slices barely had anything on them. It wasn’t bad overall, I just wish they’d been a little more generous.
0
Reply
harry-Kennamore
May 15, 2026
"Solid Pizza for a Fair Price"
I grabbed a pizza from here the other night when I didn’t feel like cooking, it hit the spot. Nothing overly fancy, but the pizza was good, the portions felt fair, and the price made it feel worth it. I’d definitely go back when I’m craving something easy and reliable.
0
Reply
jean_Roark94
May 14, 2026
"Really nice staff, right?"
The staff at Aurelio’s were so friendly when I ordered. They greeted me right away and didn’t make me feel rushed at all, even though I had a couple questions. It just made the whole experience feel easy and pleasant, you know? I’d definitely go back just because of that.
0
Reply
hello_nina127
May 13, 2026
"The pizza was still hot when it..."
The pizza was still hot when it got here, which was great. that makes such a difference because when it arrives cold, it’s like..
0
Reply
MinnieBullock
April 27, 2026
"Decent, but I expected fresher"
The pizza was fine, I guess. Some of the toppings did taste fresh, and the cheese was actually good, but the veggies seemed a little past their best. It wasn’t bad by any means, just a bit disappointing because I politely expected it to taste fresher overall.
0
Reply
RubenGehrmann_80
April 21, 2026
"Showed up faster than I expected"
I ordered from Aurelio’s the delivery was quicker than I thought it would be. I was mostly just paying attention to whether the pizza would still be hot when it got here, and it definitely was. I didn’t have to keep checking the door or wondering where it was, which was nice. Super easy order overall, no complaints
0
Reply
traci_Lewis76
April 12, 2026
"Finally, an order that didn’t get messed up"
I ordered a couple pizzas and some sides, and I was kind of expecting something to be wrong because that usually seems to happen to me. But this time everything showed up exactly how I entered it. No missing toppings, no random wrong items, nothing. It was a relief for once, and it made the whole ordering process feel a lot less frustrating.
0
Reply
benjaminconaway2684
April 12, 2026
"Big portions, but I’m a little less sure now"
The slices were seriously huge, and I definitely left full with plenty of leftovers for later. That part was great, but for some reason the overall experience didn’t leave me feeling as confident about coming back as I expected...
0
Reply
Dustin_carter78
March 16, 2026
"Tables and floors could’ve been cleaner"
The floor was kind of sticky, and the tables didn’t feel as clean as they should’ve been. It wasn’t a huge deal, but it definitely seemed preventable with a quick wipe-down and mop.
0
Reply
richard1992
March 03, 2026
"Literally Something for Everyone"
I really like how many choices Aurelio’s has on the menu. Pizza is obviously the big thing, but they also have pasta, sandwiches, salads, and tons of toppings. It’s literally perfect when everyone in the family wants something different. Ordering was easy, and nobody had to settle for something they didn’t want.
0
Reply
johndigregorio9777
February 21, 2026
"I thought the pizza was good overall..."
I thought the pizza was good overall. The sauce had a nice flavor and everything tasted fresh. The crust could’ve been a little crispier, though. It was better than some other places I’ve tried, but...
0
Reply
Kay_birnbaum88
February 12, 2026
"It was one of those busy nights where..."
It was one of those busy nights where dinner kind of snuck up on us, so we decided to grab pizza. I placed the order expecting a bit of a wait, but it was ready way faster than I thought. When I got there, pickup was super easy, no confusion or long standing around. I was in and out in just a few minutes, which was exactly what I needed that night.
0
Reply
WilliamPhillips
February 04, 2026
"Crust was just okay, and the reminders were a bit much"
I ordered from Aurelio’s and the pizza was decent overall, but the crust didn’t really do it for me. Some bites had a nice chew, but other parts were dry and kind of hard, so it felt a little inconsistent.
The sauce and toppings were fine, and I’d probably eat it again, but it’s not my favorite. Also, the reminders to order/review were way too aggressive, which got annoying fast. I just wish the crust tasted a little fresher and more even
The sauce and toppings were fine, and I’d probably eat it again, but it’s not my favorite. Also, the reminders to order/review were way too aggressive, which got annoying fast. I just wish the crust tasted a little fresher and more even
0
Reply
Have a question about Aurelio's Pizza?
Log in to ask your Aurelio's Pizza question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
